Poker and The New Anti-Internet Gaming Law

Reprinted with permission from Professor I Nelson Rose*, Whittier Law School, Costa Mesa, CA.

Senator Bill Frist (R.-TN), doesn't want to be President - he wants to be Dictator.

Frist, the majority leader of the U.S. Senate, used his position of power to ram through the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006. He didn't even give the members of Congress a chance to read the bill. They were told about it late Friday night, mere minutes before they recessed to campaign for reelection.

Frist cynically attached his pet anti-Internet gaming bill to a completely unrelated bill dealing with port security, so no one would dare vote against it.

No matter how you feel about Internet gaming, this is not the way laws should be made in this country.

The only good thing to come out of this fiasco is we now know what type of hypocrite Bill Frist is.

Frist is one of the most active advocates of American values.

Well, one American value is that people get to know what they are voting for.

Even giving him the benefit of the doubt, that he really cared about Internet gambling, he appointed himself the decider of how America should handle the issue.

But, in fact, Frist never showed any interest in Internet gaming until he decided to run for President.

Having run political campaigns, I can tell you he first conducted polls and focus groups and hired campaign consultants. They told him that he could score a few points with his right-wing religious base by coming out against online gambling.

So Frist threw the idea of outlawing Internet gaming into a speech in Iowa, where the first presidential caucuses will be held in 2008. The post-speech polls and focus group must have been positive, because he next announced it as a legislative priority, even though almost no one else in Congress, or America, cares much about the issue.

The bill immediately spooked the entire industry.

Giants like PartyPoker announced that they would no longer take bets from the U.S. Frist actually managed to cause as much economic damage as an Islamist terrorist attack: billions of dollars were wiped out overnight, when online stocks fell more than 50%.

This was probably an overreaction, since the new law will not actually do much. The only new crime created is accepting funds for unlawful Internet gambling, defined as violating some other federal, state or tribal law. It doesn't make operators much more guilty than they already were.

For example, David Carruthers, Chief Executive of BetOnSports, was arrested changing planes in Dallas, and served with a 27-page long indictment. Now the indictment would be 28 pages.

On the other hand, Internet poker operators have claimed that they are not violating any federal or state law. If that is true, they are still not guilty of a crime.

This law is supposedly designed to stop money transfers. Bizarrely, banks and payment processors cannot be charged with this new crime.

The federal regulators have 270 days to come up with new regulations for these money transferors.

But the biggest player, Neteller, will take the position that it is not subject to U.S. regulations, since it is not an U.S. financial institution. The only danger is that banks might be told they can't send money to Neteller.

Prosecutors can get injunctions to prevent Internet Service Providers from hosting gambling sites and affiliates, but these already are, or will be, on foreign servers.

Can anything be done about this new law?

Unfortunately, no. Using its police powers, Congress can do just about anything to any form of gambling.

It just would have been nice if they had read the bill before they voted.

END

Gambling and the Law (R) is a registered trademark of Professor I Nelson Rose, Whittier Law School, Costa Mesa, CA.

Copyright 2006.

* Professor I Nelson Rose is recognized as one of the world's leading experts on gambling law. His latest books, Gaming Law: Cases and Materials and Internet Gaming Law, are available through his website, www.GamblingAndTheLaw.com.

More Current Affairs Articles

Day 1 of WSOP Winter Bayou Poker Challenge Closes
12am Tue Dec 9th, 2008

The Harrah’s New Orleans Winter Bayou Poker Challenge, a WSOP Satellite Event, kicked off Monday at Harrah's Casino in New Orleans.

Bill to Legalize Online Poker & Online Gambling Introduced by Barney Frank
12pm Fri Apr 27th, 2007

Bill Creates Exemption for Properly Licensed Operators to UIGEA's Ban

Frank to Introduce UIGEA Repeal Bill Today- Online Poker Applauds
1am Thu Apr 26th, 2007

U.S. House Financial Services Committee Chairman Barney Frank's press office confirmed that today at 10am ET, Frank will hold a press conference to discuss legislation he is introducing to repeal the controversial Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIGEA), which Frank has called "one of the stupidest things I ever saw."

UIGEA Repeal Meetings Give Hope to Online Poker Players
12am Sat Apr 21st, 2007

Several meetings were held this past week in Washington DC to strategize how to challenge the U.S. Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIGEA), which signals hope for online poker players that UIGEA repeal efforts are coming to a climax in the coming months.

USA loses WTO Appeal in Online Poker & Online Gambling Case
12am Mon Apr 2nd, 2007

The World Trade Organization (WTO) ruled again March 30 against an appeal by the United States in a long-running David versus Goliath case brought by the tiny Caribbean nation of Antigua and Barbuda against the United States initially in 2003 alleging that the U.S. discriminates against online gambling (including online poker) companies that are not located within the United States.

New Web Gambling Study Could Lead to Legal Online Poker in USA Again
3am Mon Mar 19th, 2007

Two Nevada lawmakers are working on legislation for an 18-month study of online gambling to determine whether online gambling can be effectively regulated in the United States.

Kyl asks Bush to Enforce UIGEA to Counter Frank's Repeal of the Anti-Online Poker Bill
12am Mon Mar 19th, 2007

Arizona Senator Jon Kyl (R) sent President George W. Bush a letter thanking him for his protection of family values and urging him to act immediately in ensuring that the forthcoming regulations for the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIGEA) are as strictly enforced as possible.

EU May Challenge UIGEA Outlawing Online Poker and Online Gambling Payments
9am Wed Jan 31st, 2007

The European Union's (EU) top financial regulator, Internal Market Commissioner Charlie McCreevy, told the European Parliament on Tuesday that the United States is using "protectionist" legislation to stop foreign online poker and gambling companies entering the US online betting market, and that it may trigger legal action before the World Trade Organisation (WTO).

Does U.S. Want Online Poker & Online Gambling All To Themselves?
6am Mon Jan 29th, 2007

The respected UK newspaper The Telegraph carried a hard hitting article this weekend which suggested that the US crackdown on online gaming, including online poker, may not be so much about morals as hard cash.

PPA President's State of Poker Address
12am Fri Jan 26th, 2007

In parallel to the 'State of the Union' address US Presidents traditionally delivers to Congress each January, Michael Bolcerek, president of the Poker Players Alliance (PPA), posted a 'State of Poker' address on the organization's web site, reviewing where poker is today and where, with poker players' help, it can go in the future.