No Withholding Taxes on Poker Tourneys

The IRS has decided that every poker operator in the United States will have to report anyone who wins more than $5,000 in a poker tournament.

To get around the fact that Congress never authorized this, IRS is pretending to require that 25% or more of these winners' prizes have to be withheld by the poker operators and forwarded to the IRS.

That is only partially true.

Buried in the IRS's published statement changing the tax treatment of poker tournaments is the following sentence:

"The IRS will not assert any liability for additional tax or additions to tax for violations of any withholding obligation with respect to amounts paid to winners of poker tournaments... provided that the poker tournament sponsor meets all of the requirements for information reporting" under the tax code and regulations.

What this means is the IRS has declared that poker tournament operators are absolutely required to withhold at least 25%, but that the IRS won't add any tax penalties or fines to operators who voluntarily turn in their big tourney winners.

I hate laws like this.

What apparently happened was that when word got out that the IRS was going to devastate poker tournaments, land-based casinos lobbied for a compromise. This is exactly what lobbyists are supposed to do, assuming they cannot get the regulator to completely drop the idea.

The result is better for players. As one example: If withholding were required, anyone who won a $10,000 buy-in to the WSOP would actually collect only $7,500. Now, the player wins the seat, but is reported on a Form W-2G to the IRS.

Of course, this is still bad news for winners. A W-2G is practically an invitation to be audited.

The compromise has created other problems. Some land-based card clubs and casinos are withholding while others are not. This is not just because this "waiver of liability," as the IRS calls it, is hard to find and decode. Conservative lawyers and accountants might still advise their clients to send a chunk of big winners' prizes to the IRS.

The problem is that the IRS says it is interpreting the Internal Revenue Code, which contains criminal penalties for non-compliance. Notice that the IRS only promised not to impose "additional tax or additions to tax."

Plus, the actions of the IRS are highly questionable.

When people think of laws, they naturally think of statutes passed by legislatures, like Congress. Every adult knows there is another set of laws that is at least as important in their everyday life: regulations from government agencies, like the IRS. Both statutes and regulations require public input.

We know what happens when the public is not allowed its say. You end up with statutes like the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act, or this new rule on poker tournaments from the IRS.

For the IRS did not propose a regulation. Nothing was published. There was no opportunity for card rooms, let alone players, to object.

The IRS simply declared that it was reinterpreting a law passed by Congress in 1976, containing a term, "wagering pool," which dates back to the 1950s. Nobody, before now, thought "wagering pool" included poker or other games. In fact, everyone knew it didn't, because it is exclusively lumped in with lotteries and bookmaking.

The IRS has now declared that when Congress required withholding of "wagering pools," it meant to include poker tournaments. But, the IRS is giving a free pass to every card room and casino which openly violate a law passed by Congress, so long as they voluntarily turn in their big winners.

-- END -- Copyright 2008.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Professor I Nelson Rose is recognized as one of the world's leading authorities on gambling law, and is a consultant and expert witness for governments and industry. His latest books, GAMING LAW: CASES AND MATERIALS and INTERNET GAMING LAW, are available through his website: GAMBLINGANDTHELAW.com.

More Poker News Articles

Fabrice Soulier Joins Everest Poker's Pro Roster
12am Thu Nov 26th, 2009

To further strengthen its support for French poker in anticipation of the opening of that market, Everest Poker has signed renowned French poker pro Fabrice Soulier as its latest ambassador.

HHPT Co-Sponsors Bayou Poker Challenge Ladies Event Dec. 20
12am Wed Nov 25th, 2009

The HighHeelsPokerTour (HHPT), the first all women's poker tour launched on the East coast, will wrap up their 2009 schedule at Harrah's New Orleans on December 20th where they will co-sponsor the Ladies Event #14 no-limit Hold'em at 12 pm.

OPPAGA Reports on Florida's Online Poker Options
12am Tue Nov 24th, 2009

Given that UIGEA permits individual states to regulate online poker, the Florida Legislature's Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability (OPPAGA) published a report this week presenting three options available to Florida State lawmakers in order to protect consumers from unlawful internet poker: regulate it, prohibit it, or carry on with the status quo pending federal legislation.

BC Poker Champion Arrested, Charged with Manslaughter
12am Tue Nov 24th, 2009

Just two days after taking down the BC Poker Championships Main Event, Sophon Sek of Cloverdale, BC, was arrested in connection with one of the most storied crimes in the Province's history.

Local Businessman Bags European Poker Tour Vilamoura Bling
12am Sun Nov 22nd, 2009

The European Poker Tour rolled into the Casino Vilamoura last week, instantly generating the richest poker prize pool in the nation of Portugal's history.

Keikoan Captures Harvey's Lake Tahoe WSOPC Championship
12am Thu Nov 19th, 2009

This week marked the finale of the biggest annual tournament series in Northern Nevada, the WSOP Circuit championship at Harvey's Lake Tahoe. While the Main Event saw only a modest turnout, it did boast of a tough final table, and a WSOP bracelet owner as the eventual champion.

WSOP Main Event Champ Joe Cada to Appear on Letterman
12am Wed Nov 18th, 2009

The poker world will receive some late night attention tonight as "The Kid" Joe Cada, the youngest champion in the four decade history of the World Series of Poker Main Event, takes a seat next to embattled talk show host David Letterman.

First Korean Champ of Asia Pacific Poker Tour Crowned in Cebu
12am Tue Nov 17th, 2009

Another stop on the Asia Pacific Poker Tour is in the books, this time it's the APPT Cebu in the Philippines, and for the very first time a Korean player has come out on top.

Pollack Done as Commish of World Series of Poker
12am Sat Nov 14th, 2009

Just three days after crowning Joe Cada as the 2009 Main Event champion, officially closing the special 40th anniversary run of the World Series of Poker, Jeffrey Pollack has resigned his post as Commissioner of the WSOP.

Durrrr Signs as Team Full Tilt's Youngest Member
12am Wed Nov 11th, 2009

Tom "durrrr" Dwan is the newest member of Team Full Tilt, the online site's highest level of affiliation. At 23, Dwan is the youngest of the now 14-person team. The high stakes cash phenomenon was nominated for induction this year into the Poker Hall of Fame until the Hall of Fame Governing Council decided he was too young to meet the "has stood the test of time" qualification.