UIGEA Hearing: Enforcing Vague UIGEA Is a Struggle Say Feds

The Associate Press released a commentary about testimoney at Wednesday's US Congressional hearing on implementing the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006 (UIGEA), which in summary describes how officials from Treasury and the Federal Reserve testified that they are so confused about what the "unlawful" part of UIGEA means, that it is unusually hard for them to figure out how to implement it.

Here is the entire AP release, authored by Erica Werner:

WASHINGTON (AP) - Congress' ban on Internet gambling is so vague that figuring out how to enforce it is a struggle, say federal officials charged with the task.

"I think it is very difficult without having more of a bright line about what is intended to be unlawful Internet gambling," Louise Roseman, head of the Federal Reserve's bank operations division, told a House hearing Wednesday.

"The challenge we have is interpreting something, particularly federal laws, that Congress itself isn't sure what they mean," she said.

Congress passed the ban with little notice in 2006 when Senate Republicans, pushed by then-Majority Leader Bill Frist, attached it to an unrelated port security bill in a rush of year-end legislation.

Internet gambling already was considered mostly illegal in the U.S., but the games are played by many U.S. residents on sites hosted overseas in a business worth more than $15.5 billion a year. U.S. bettors have been estimated to provide at least half that revenue.

The congressional ban sought to explicitly outlaw Internet gambling but didn't offer a clear definition everyone could agree on, instead referring to existing federal and state laws which themselves provoke differing interpretations. It put the burden on financial institutions by prohibiting them from accepting payments from credit cards, checks or electronic fund transfers to settle online wagers.

That's led to complaints from the financial services industry about the difficulty of determining where payments are going, especially because online betting businesses can disguise themselves with relative ease.

It "makes financial institutions the police, prosecutors, and judges in place of real law enforcement officers," Wayne Abernathy of the American Bankers Association told a House Financial Services subcommittee Wednesday.

Regulations proposed by the U.S. Treasury and the Federal Reserve last fall would apply to the gambling business' bank- generally not to the gambler's bank- and require it to use due diligence to ascertain the nature of its customer's business and ensure it is not processing illegal Internet gambling payments. The regulation doesn't attempt a definition of illegal online gambling, since Congress didn't give one.

The regulations have drawn numerous comments from agitated bankers, poker players, and others. Officials from Treasury and the Fed both testified Wednesday to challenges in finalizing the regulations.

Poker players contend they're not covered. Horse-racing was exempted by Congress, yet without settling definitively whether online wagering on races breaks the law.

"A rather bizarre piece of legislation," said House Financial Services Committee Chairman Barney Frank, D-Mass., who has introduced a bill to overturn it.

The law has caused international disputes, including an investigation launched earlier this month by the European Union after European betting companies complained that Washington's actions against them were infringing world trade rules. In the United Kingdom and some other countries, Internet gambling is largely legal.

Nevada's casino industry is neutral on the regulations, supporting a bill written by Rep. Shelley Berkley, D-Nev., that would require a study of online gambling.

(This version updates an earlier released version, which CORRECTS in 3rd paragraph to 'itself' instead of 'themselves' CORRECTS spelling of horse racing.)

More Poker News Articles

High Stakes Poker Re-ups with the Game Show Network
12am Thu Jul 24th, 2008

Just when it looked like the Game Show Network would shift to a pokerless schedule, it has been announced that High Stakes Poker will be back for another season. HSP will begin filming Season Five episodes in September.

SirWatts Electric at World Poker Tour Bellagio Cup
12am Sun Jul 20th, 2008

Just as the World Series of Poker Main Event left on a 117-day break, a new World Poker Tour millionaire was being crowned at the Bellagio. Some 446 entrants ponied up the $15,000 buy-in, creating a prize pool worth $6,489,300. More than $1.6 million will go to Canadian Michael "SirWatts" Watson, winner of Bellagio Cup VI.

World Poker Tour Finds New Home on Fox Sports Net
12am Sat Jul 19th, 2008

It was announced Thursday that World Poker Tour Enterprises has reached an agreement with Fox Sports Network (FSN) to broadcast Season VII of the WPT series. Tournaments are already underway for the new season, which will consist of 26 one-hour episodes.

EGBA Sets New Best Practice Standards for Responsible Gaming
12am Wed Jul 16th, 2008

The European Gaming and Betting Association (EGBA), in support of their mission to promote fair competition for European-licensed operators and consumer choice in a regulated European online gaming market. has launched a new set of best practices to ensure consistent standards of player protection, fair gaming and responsible operator behavior in the European online poker, Internet gaming and betting environment.

World Poker Association Changes Membership Terms
12am Wed Jul 16th, 2008

The new leadership under Founder and present Chairman of the World Poker Association (WPA), Jesse Jones, has taken immediate measures to address the needs of the over 1400 members who have joined the WPA to date, through several key membership changes. These changes include:

Stanley Ho's IPO Reveals Setbacks Since Macau Regulation, Competition Arrive
12am Wed Jul 16th, 2008

The delayed listing of Stanley Ho's Sociedade de Jogos de Macau Holdings (SJM) group on Hong Kong's Stock Exchange until today, 16 July, is characteristic of the many challenges the firm has faced since 2002, when foreign operators were allowed to build casinos, and regulations increased. Since then, the 86-year old billionaire's four decade dominance of the Portuguese colony's gaming market, determining where and when you could play poker has waned.

'November Nine' Final Table of the World Series of Poker Is Set
12am Tue Jul 15th, 2008

From 6,844 to nine, the players for the final table of the Main Event of the 39th World Series of Poker have now emerged after nearly two weeks at the tables. The so-called 'November Nine' will return on November 9 after a 117 day hiatus as the most well prepared final table in poker history, as well as being guinea pigs for this first-ever delayed final table experiment.

Poker Tournaments in Bars -- The New Prohibition?
12am Mon Jul 14th, 2008

While the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIGEA) has devastated internet poker, separate, quiet battles are being fought, and won, to make poker legal in bars under state laws.

'November Nine' Emerge Today at World Series of Poker, Hellmuth Places 45th
12am Mon Jul 14th, 2008

Today, July 14, is a big day at the World Series of Poker, when the three remaining tables of the Main Event will be trimmed to one, from the 27 players starting play today Day 7. That means that today we will learn the identities of the 'November Nine', the nine finalists who will return November 9 to play out the final table under the television spotlights.

Biggest $250,000 Guaranteed Poker Tournament in Bodog History Coming
12am Mon Jul 14th, 2008

History will be made this summer at Bodog Poker, as the online poker powerhouse hosts its largest guaranteed prize pool tournament ever on Sunday, Aug. 10, at 4 p.m. EST, with a guaranteed $250,000 in total prize money to be awarded-- regardless of the number of registrants.