Poker Odds Calculator
Pokerstars
Romania  Dutch  Hungarian  Portuguese  France
Poker Tournament Information »
PokerPages > Poker News > Poker News

Poker News - Poker News

WSJ Says Legalize and Regulate Online Poker and Online Gambling in USA

by PokerPages.com
Fri, Apr 11th, 2008 @ 12:00am

The Wall Street Journal yesterday published an op-ed piece pointing out how the European Union is weighing a similar World Trade Organization case as Antigua's against United States online poker and online gambling protectionism and its possible effects, giving a good summary of the U.S stance, and stressing overall that the USA should legalize and regulate online gambling.

The article appears below in its entirety:

Time to Fold

FROM April 10 WALL STREET JOURNAL EUROPE

A trans-Atlantic spat over online gambling may help rewrite the rules of the game for Internet commerce across borders. For a change, the Europeans stand on the side of free trade, while America dabbles in regulatory overreach.

The European Union last month launched an internal probe into whether the U.S. Justice Department selectively enforces its antigambling laws against European online firms that offer wagers on sports events. Brussels is making a narrow legal point that Washington discriminates against Europeans by simultaneously permitting U.S. Internet horse betting. That's against World Trade Organization rules, and the case may end up there.

The U.S. last year lost a similar WTO online gambling case against Antigua and Barbuda. The island nation argued that U.S. online gambling rules violated Washington's GATT commitments to open its market in "recreational, cultural and sporting services." The U.S. countered that its policies were justified to protect public morals and public order, a legitimate exception under WTO rules. But the WTO panel ruled that America wasn't applying its restrictions equally to foreigners and domestic operators. U.S. online horse-betting sites aren't banned.

Washington could have stood down then. Instead, it is "threatening and pressing criminal prosecutions, forfeitures and other enforcement actions against foreign online gaming operators," according to the London-based Remote Gambling Association, which took the complaint to the EU. In doing so, Washington is also practicing a form of universal jurisdiction by applying domestic law to foreigners beyond its borders - a legal interpretation that the U.S. has, rightly, condemned in other cases.

In 2006, the former chairman of U.K.-based gambling firm Sportingbet, Peter Dicks, was detained in New York. The Briton was wanted in Louisiana on online gambling charges. Then-New York Governor George Pataki declined to sign a warrant extraditing him, and he was released. Many European industry executives now no longer stop over in the U.S., let alone visit the country, for fear of arrest. "There is a list of wanted people but nobody knows who's on it," said Clive Hawswood of the Remote Gambling Association.

Justice has continued to threaten these companies even though the alleged transgressions are all in the past, the association's complaint says. The sites stopped offering their services to U.S. customers after the U.S. tightened its antigambling laws in 2006. The Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act requires financial institutions to identify and block gambling-related payments.

As it happens, the U.S. ban on online betting is also impractical. At a Congressional hearing last week, the American Bankers Association explained how difficult it is to identify customers engaged in illegal Internet games. The association's Wayne Abernathy said the law makes banks "police, prosecutors, judges and executing marshals in place of real enforcement officers."

We have our differences with House Financial Services Chairman Barney Frank, but he may have been on to something when he introduced a bill to exempt licensed operators from the ban. Gambling is a vice, and social problems attach themselves to it. By legalizing and regulating the business, however, Washington could more effectively battle such problems as underage gambling and addiction. It would also avoid unnecessary trade tiffs with its leading commercial partners. And it would exempt cyberspace from overaggressive regulators, in America or anywhere else.

Read Related Article:

  • Antigua to Reject Late USA Proposal to End WTO Online Poker-Gambling Dispute
  •  

     
     

    More Poker News Articles

    Sweden Asks ECJ Questions Impacting European Gaming Monopoly Policy
    12am Fri Oct 10th, 2008

    Sweden sent five questions to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) on October 8th concerning the rights of government-owned online poker and Internet gambling monopolies to limit foreign competition under EC rules. Though some say Sweden did so to head off an ECJ case, all agree that answers to this 'comprehensive set of questions' will largely impact the future of the European gambling market.

    Neteller's New Name: Neovia Financial- Poker Players Take Note
    12am Fri Oct 10th, 2008

    In an apparent related effort to distance themselves from past entanglements with the DOJ over internet gambling in the USA, online payment solutions provider Neteller has proposed to change its name to Neovia Financial at its extraordinary general meeting (EGM) on 11 November.

    Bulgaria is Bwin's Latest European Online Poker Expansion
    12am Fri Oct 10th, 2008

    The Vienna-listed online gambling group Bwin continues to roll out its targeted expansion into European online poker, using the subsidiary Ongame platform to launch a Bulgarian language and full localized website.

    Sandman to Gov Beshear: Regulate Online Poker & Internet Gambling Sites
    12am Thu Oct 9th, 2008

    Jeffrey Sandman, spokesperson for the Safe and Secure Internet Gambling Initiative, issued a statement that appeals to Kentucky Governor Steve Beshar to stop the court case to seize 141 online gambling domain names (including those for major online poker sites as Bodog, CakePoker, Full Tilt Poker, Ultimate Bet, and PokerStars). Instead, the governor is encouraged to support legislation to regulate and tax Internet Gambling, which would extend the way he now supports state residents' rights to bet on horse racing online and in casinos, and would address concerns regarding minors and problem gamblers.

    A Modest Proposal Regarding Poker
    12am Thu Oct 9th, 2008

    Is poker a game of skill?

    Jimmy McSweeney wins Ladbrokes Irish Poker Festival
    12am Thu Oct 9th, 2008

    The Irish Winter Festival in Killarney had a capacity-straining record-setting 832 entrants, but it was Jimmy McSweeney of Cork Ireland who took home the first prize of an even 100,000 Euros.

    Judge to Rule Oct 15 on Kentucky Online Poker Domain Seizure
    12am Wed Oct 8th, 2008

    After hearing arguments in a Franklin County courtroom yesterday from both sides regarding Kentucky Governor Steve Beshear's directive to seize 141 online gambling domains, including such major online poker sites as Bodog, CakePoker, Full Tilt Poker, Ultimate Bet, and PokerStars, Judge Thomas Wingate stated that he needs one week to review both sides of the case, so he plans to announce his final historic ruling on October 15th.

    Free Tuition from Online Poker Tourney Causing Row in Canada
    12am Wed Oct 8th, 2008

    The student union at Cape Breton University in the Nova Scotia province of Canada has endorsed an online poker site that offers Canadian students the chance to win free tuition as prizes when they play in weekly online poker tournaments.

    Hungarian Csaba Toth Joins Team RedKings as 3rd Pro Poker Member
    12am Wed Oct 8th, 2008

    RedKings Poker just announced the signing of new Hungarian Poker talent Csaba Toth to join their live events team, Team RedKings. The team already boasts two highly respected young Scandinavian players: Swedish pro Jesper Hoog and Finnish sensation Toni Ojala. Csaba will be the third professional team member.

    Mercier Tops Juanda for European Poker Tour London High Roller Crown
    12am Wed Oct 8th, 2008

    The only poker player hotter than WSOPE Main Event winner John Juanda is Jason Mercier. Since capturing the EPT San Remo title in April, Mercier has put together seven cashes and three final tables. His latest final table appearance ended Thursday with a win in the EPT London High Rollers Event, worth GBP 516,000 (~ $1 million USD).

    Download Poker Software
    PokerPages
    Newsletter
    Online Poker »
    Poker News »
    Blog Coverage


    Top News
    Top Tournaments